Pickup trucks are popular for their ability to haul and tow various items, but not all trucks are reliable. Here are 12 models you should think twice about before buying.
Haul of Shame — 12 Pickup Trucks You’ll Regret Owning
If you've ever felt the thrill of owning a pickup truck, you may already know that not all are created equal. Some can quickly turn into a nightmare, leaving owners frustrated and disappointed. This article dives into the 12 pickup trucks you’ll regret owning, helping prospective buyers avoid buyers' remorse when it comes to their next vehicle.
How We Chose Our Lineup
Careful research was conducted to create this list, spanning several decades of pickup history. We analyzed reports of mechanical issues, reliability problems, and even gathered personal accounts from truck enthusiasts. While the options discussed here have garnered a notorious reputation, it's worth noting that some of these trucks remain beloved by niche audiences. Here’s a review of some of the most regrettable picks
2001-2007 Ford Explorer Sport Trac
While the 2001-2007 Ford Explorer Sport Trac might seem appealing with its unique design, it's plagued with reliability issues that can leave owners in dire straits. Common problems include nasty coolant leaks due to a plastic intake manifold that cracks and faulty transmissions frequently resulting in failure.
These transmitters prompted Ford to issue numerous service bulletins to address fluid leaks and internal failures. Additionally, overheating problems caused by a PCM software issue resulted in cracked coolant reservoirs and blown radiators, proving that this pickup fails to deliver the dependability you'd expect from a vehicle designed for hard work.
2003-2004 Chevy SSR
The Chevy SSR, launched in 2003 with high hopes, featured an eye-catching design but delivered less than enthusiasts expected. Sporting a 5.3-L V-8 engine that offered only 300 horsepower to a hefty frame, it was a let-down regarding performance, especially when competing against lighter roadsters. Even with a modified version released in 2005, the SSR could not gain traction in sales and was discontinued in 2006, marking it as one of the more regrettable pickups on the market.
2003-2006 Subaru Baja
Though likely adored by some, the Subaru Baja isn’t the pickup to count on for serious hauling. Largely a station wagon with a truck bed, it suffers from significant head gasket issues, leaving many owners frustrated. While it may accommodate four adults, legroom in the back seat is cramped, rendering it uncomfortable for anyone taller than average. Reviews highlight how the issues persisted even after earlier models claimed to have resolved them.
1997-2004 Dodge Dakota
Dodge Dakota’s second-generation models (1997 - 2004) are notorious for mechanical failures. Engine problems abound, including cam sensor failures, manifold bolts breaking off, and pesky coolant and oil leaks. The truck's reputation has been sullied further due to brake and suspension complaints, resulting in a bad experience for many owners. The Dakota line ended production in 2011, in part due to these challenges.
1962-1964 Jeep Gladiator
The earlier iteration of the Jeep Gladiator had a lot going for it. It was built tough and stylish, but repeated complaints about the engine severely hindered its reputation. The design flaw concerning motor mounts led to frequent gasket leaks and oil starvation issues, severely impacting performance. The resolution of these problems didn’t occur until 1965, leaving a long-lasting negative impression on the truck's history.
2025 Tesla Cybertruck
With the anticipated release of the Tesla Cybertruck set for 2025, potential buyers should be cautious. Concerns flared due to reported quality issues like rust susceptibility and performance difficulties, particularly in cold weather. A purchasing agreement has included troubling resale clauses, further muddling the potential for a good investment. Without improvements to design and quality, many are questioning if the hype will align with reality.
1979-1984 VW Rabbit Pickup
Cute and quaint, the VW Rabbit Pickup is more talk than concern. While it offered good gas mileage, it’s infamous for hidden rust issues in frame members. This can lead to structural failure, posing significant safety risks. Additional common complaints include electrical issues and lackluster performance. Investing in a Rabbit Pickup may be charming, but it’s a gamble best avoided.
1961 – 1965 Corvair Rampside Pickup
Chevrolet experimented with a quirky design in the Corvair Rampside Pickup, merging features that led to unstable handling and rust problems. Its raised loading area undercuts its utility, making it impractical for carrying larger items. With an unusual layout, this half-van, half-truck is often remembered for the issues that plagued the entire Corvair lineup.
1982 – 1984 Dodge Rampage
The Dodge Rampage, a subcompact effort from Dodge, aimed at making a sportier pickup but ultimately failed. Owners complain of terrible build quality, gutless performance, and safety concerns. Though it has a certain aesthetic appeal, reports of reliability are predominantly negative, leading to its short production run.
2020 – 2024 Jeep Gladiator
The revival of the Jeep Gladiator aimed to honor its legacy but isn’t without a litany of issues. Owners have reported all sorts of transmission problems, ranging from harsh shifts to complete failures. Complaints of a severe “Death Wobble” while driving have emerged alongside electrical nightmares. These concerns have put this model's reputation at risk, mirroring some of the legacy issues of its predecessors.
2019 Ford F350
The 2019 Ford F350 faced significant scrutiny concerning its steering performance, with users lamenting a frustrating “Death Wobble.” Further issues range from concerns about engine reliability to major risks of fires related to the diesel engine block heater. For those reliant on performance and reliability, these facts taint the allure of the Super Duty range.
2010 Nissan Titan
The first-generation Nissan Titan sought to make an impact in the full-sized truck market but fell victim to numerous issues. Problems with overheating rear axles and fuel pump failures have led to some serious headaches for owners. While later generations improved, the initial models carry a considerable burden of reputational flaws.
Avoiding Buyer’s Remorse
Purchasing a pickup truck isn't a decision to be taken lightly, especially when turning over your hard-earned money for a vehicle that could lead to endless problems. All the trucks on this list offer a glimpse into the pitfalls of poorly-designed vehicles, as challenges stem from inappropriate materials, engine issues, or design flaws. Take caution when choosing your next truck to avoid being stranded on the side of the road! Do you have tales of regret from owning any of these models? Share your story today!