Scotty Kilmer, a seasoned mechanic with five decades of experience, has issued candid warnings about purchasing new trucks and SUVs, with particular emphasis on recent Toyota and Ford models. His insights identify reliability and value as critical factors, while highlighting industry trends buyers can’t afford to overlook.
Concerns with New Toyota Trucks and SUVs
Kilmer specifically cautions against new Toyota Tundra, Sequoia, 4Runner, and Land Cruiser vehicles. The main issue lies in their adoption of the twin-turbo V6 engine, which he claims is underpowered for these large vehicles. This design change, while fuel-efficient, has led to numerous customer complaints and recurring performance concerns. Kilmer states these recent models have been plagued by multiple recalls and the use of lower-quality components—most notably since disruptions during the Covid-19 pandemic. In his view, these factors undermine Toyota’s historically strong reputation for durability in its larger vehicles.
Ford Trucks Face Reliability Challenges
While Ford trucks consistently top sales charts, Kilmer highlights their significant reliability setbacks. The brand has set a record with 89 recalls in the United States within a single year, raising red flags about overall build quality. He points especially to problems in U.S. factory management and staffing that have impacted manufacturing standards. Despite aggressive marketing and consumer popularity, these issues suggest that reliability can no longer be assumed for new Ford trucks.
Industry-Wide Issues Undermine New Pickups
Kilmer’s skepticism extends well beyond just Toyota and Ford. He asserts that no brand currently offers a new pickup truck that meets his standards for trustworthiness. Broad industry challenges—including ongoing supply chain disruptions, inconsistency in materials sourcing, and managerial missteps—have led to declining assembly standards across the pickup segment. Buyers seeking to maximize vehicle longevity and resale value are, according to Kilmer, potentially better served by sidestepping the new model year offerings entirely.
Preferred Alternatives: Pre-Owned and Recent Used Models
For those still seeking a dependable truck, Kilmer recommends looking at pre-owned vehicles. He points out that pre-2024 Toyota Tundras and pre-2023 Toyota Tacomas have a reputation for robustness without the issues plaguing current releases. Similarly, the 2023 Nissan Frontier and used Nissan Titans stand out as solid choices. These models benefit from proven drivetrains, long-term reliability data, and avoidance of more recent production shortcuts. Buyers gravitating toward these options may find a better balance of durability, fewer recalls, and lower maintenance requirements.
The Continued Strength of Toyota Hybrids
Outside the truck segment, Kilmer continues to endorse Toyota’s line of smaller hybrids—specifically the Camry, RAV4, Prius, and Corolla. He characterizes these vehicles as “indestructible,” praising their proven hybrid systems and exemplary track records for longevity. These models have consistently delivered high marks for reliability, cost efficiency, and owner satisfaction, establishing themselves as sensible alternatives for buyers who prioritize a worry-free ownership experience.
Making Informed Buying Decisions
Prospective truck and SUV owners should carefully weigh the insights from experienced professionals like Kilmer. The points raised about twin-turbo V6 engines, parts quality, and recall rates highlight the importance of considering both recent manufacturing shifts and broader industry challenges. By focusing on proven used models, particularly those from Toyota and Nissan, buyers may mitigate some of the widespread reliability concerns that define the current marketplace.
Summary of Key Recommendations from Scotty Kilmer
- Avoid new Toyota full-size trucks and SUVs due to engine and quality concerns
- Exercise caution with new Ford trucks as recall rates and manufacturing issues persist
- Consider trusted pre-owned models such as pre-2024 Toyota Tundra, pre-2023 Toyota Tacoma, 2023 Nissan Frontier, and used Nissan Titan
- Look to Toyota’s hybrid sedans and crossovers for longevity and value
- Assess long-term reliability by reviewing recall data, mechanic recommendations, and historical performance before making a purchasing decision
Scotty Kilmer’s advice sheds light on current automotive realities where value, dependability, and attention to product changes are more important than ever. Those looking for a reliable vehicle, particularly in the truck and SUV categories, would do well to acknowledge these expert-backed viewpoints to achieve better outcomes in both daily use and long-term satisfaction.