The battle of smartphone photo editing has taken an exciting turn. Discover how Galaxy AI photo editing on Samsung's S25 trumps Apple’s Clean Up.
In the world of smartphones, photo editing can make or break the user experience. With powerful AI tools emerging, I tested Samsung’s Galaxy AI against Apple’s Clean Up to see which offers the most impressive editing capabilities. Spoiler alert: the results were eye-opening!
The Initial Setup: A New Smartphone Journey
Being an iPhone loyalist since 2009, I was eager to dive into Android with the new Samsung S25. Equipped with AI at its core, this phone promised groundbreaking features, especially in photo editing. After using my iPhone 16 Pro Max, considered a top contender for smartphone photography, I was curious to see how Samsung’s Galaxy AI would stack up against it.
First Test: Removing a Subject
My first test focused on removing my French Bulldog, Kermit, from a photo of his plain grey bed. The challenge was unique due to the natural sunlight creating a shadow. With Samsung Galaxy AI, not only was Kermit removed flawlessly, but the complex background stitching was recreated without any visible signs of manipulation.
In stark contrast, Apple’s Clean Up struggled. The result was a blur effect, leaving Kermit's shadow intact, which completely undermined the purpose of editing. Here’s a quick score recap:
- Galaxy AI: 1
- Apple Clean Up: 0
Second Test: A Flavorful Comparison
Next up was a local coffee shop where I attempted to erase a pain au chocolat from a photo featuring two croissants. Samsung’s Galaxy AI dazzled me again. It removed the pastry seamlessly while perfectly replicating the branded paper underneath. The imagery post-editing retained realism, complete with crumbs, adding depth to the picture.
In another disappointing round, Apple’s Clean Up left shadows and a crumpled texture. The struggle continued here:
- Galaxy AI: 2
- Apple Clean Up: 0
Third Test: Challenging Liquid Physics
My third exercise included a barista pouring a Flat White. I aimed to see how well each AI could edit out the coffee cup from a dynamic image featuring a hand in motion. Samsung Galaxy AI took the challenge to heart, recreating the barista’s thumb and adding details that emphasized the pouring liquid’s action. There was a slight physics anomaly, but overall, the intelligence displayed was impressive.
Apple’s Clean Up, however, struggled again, failing to offer a satisfactory edit. Score update:
- Galaxy AI: 3
- Apple Clean Up: 0
Challenging the Limits: Complete Erasure
Feeling adventurous, I pushed both AI tools to their limits by trying to erase an entire scene in the busy coffee shop photo. Galaxy AI performed superbly; it recreated the entire environment outside the window and extended the furniture logically, maintaining continuity and realism.
In contrast, Apple’s Clean Up faltered badly, resulting in a muddled mess. Final score:
- Galaxy AI: 4
- Apple Clean Up: 0
Why Samsung’s AI Outshines Apple’s Clean Up
The results could not have been clearer: Samsung’s Galaxy AI photo editing tool significantly outperformed Apple’s Clean Up across various tests, achieving superior visual integrity and realism. With the final score showing a complete victory for Galaxy AI, it’s evident that Samsung’s commitment to enhancing AI photo editing technology has paid off.
Eye-catching capabilities of Samsung S25's AI features give it an edge not merely in marketing but in real-world applications. Apple’s approach, which aims for subtle preservation of the original photo, failed to deliver results commensurate with expectations.
Final Thoughts: AI in Smartphone Photography
While both companies adopt different philosophies in their AI design, I believe that Apple’s Clean Up should still offer effective solutions for simple edits. After using Galaxy AI, I found Apple Clean Up lacking, especially for basic tasks where competitors shine.
As smartphones continue to evolve, the strategic use of AI in photo editing will be critical. Samsung’s Galaxy AI photo editing may set new benchmarks in the future, while Apple might need to reconsider their strategies to keep pace. Embracing these changes in technology ultimately enhances the user experience, allowing for creativity and spontaneity in photography.
For anyone considering a new smartphone, the AI prowess of the Samsung S25 presents compelling arguments for switching from an iPhone, particularly for avid photographers. When it comes to iPhone 16 Pro Max review, it’s essential to recognize the context and capabilities, especially when Galaxy AI is raising the bar on photo editing further than ever.
If you’re serious about smartphone photography, Samsung’s latest offering may just have the features you’ve been longing for. Check them out today!