Pickup trucks offer practicality and performance—but not all models deliver. From nagging reliability issues to dismal performance, some trucks stand out for the wrong reasons. Explore our Haul of Shame as we uncover 12 pickup trucks that drivers wish they could forget.
Purchasing a pickup truck can be a daunting task, especially if you’re unaware of the pitfalls that some models present. Understanding the common reliability troubles and performance flaws can save you from a regrettable investment.
How We Chose Our Lineup
Extensive research was conducted to curate our list of problematic pickups. Evaluating reports on mechanical issues, design flaws, and personal experiences helped us identify the models that disappointed countless drivers. Here are the trucks that made the cut:
1. 2001-2007 Ford Explorer Sport Trac
The Ford Explorer Sport Trac might attract some attention with its compact design, but it's seriously lacking when it comes to reliability. Owners report frequent transmission failures, coolant leaks, and even overheat issues. The plastic intake manifold commonly cracks, and the truck's transmission—often leading to service bulletins regarding software updates—has left many owners seeking assistance instead of enjoying their vehicles. With parts like the wheel bearings failing after just a few thousand miles, this truck unfortunately takes the lead in our lineup.
2. 2003-2004 Chevy SSR
The Chevy SSR dazzled audiences with its flashy design when it hit the market, but once behind the wheel, owners were left disappointed. With only 300 horsepower provided by a 5.3-L V-8 engine supporting a weight exceeding 4,000 pounds, performance was less than appealing. Despite some revisions, the SSR never gained traction in sales and was ultimately discontinued after 2006.
3. 2003-2006 Subaru Baja
The Subaru Baja provides a unique take on the pickup, but it struggles to deliver utility. Intended for lighter loads, owners frequently encounter head gasket failures that plague Subaru vehicles of this era. Its limited legroom makes backseat riding uncomfortable, leaving many buyers wishing they'd chosen a conventional pickup.
4. 1997-2004 Dodge Dakota
The Dodge Dakota, while a popular midsize truck, had a notorious reputation for mechanical problems, especially in its second generation. Reports indicate issues like snapping manifold bolts and persistent oil leaks. Owners have noted numerous brake and suspension problems—even with low mileage—making this an often regrettable choice for truck enthusiasts.
5. 1962-1964 Jeep Gladiator
Though it may look sturdy, the Jeep Gladiator of its time had one glaring issue: poor engine design. Gasket leaks created oil starvation problems, leading to camshaft bearing failures. While these issues were eventually resolved, the damage to the model’s reputation lingered, discouraging potential buyers.
6. 2025 Tesla Cybertruck
Amidst the buzz surrounding the advanced Tesla Cybertruck, it hasn’t been all smooth sailing. Concerns over reliability coupled with resale complications are gradually surfacing as major issues for early buyers. With reported difficulties like rust, electrical failures, and a lack of cold-weather capability, potential buyers may want to think twice before committing to this futuristic model.
7. 1979-1984 VW Rabbit Pickup
The VW Rabbit Pickup may charm with its compact design and impressive gas mileage, but hidden rust is a significant concern. Structural integrity issues involving frame members can pose life-threatening risks if unnoticed. Buyers should conduct extensive rust inspections to avoid inheriting this risk-prone vehicle.
8. 1961-1965 Corvair Rampside Pickup
Infamous for its quirky design, the Corvair Rampside encompasses a setup that hinders practicality. With the issues of understeering and rust, along with limited flatbed space, it's a model that many drivers would prefer to steer clear of.
9. 1982-1984 Dodge Rampage
The Dodge Rampage merges a sport-like design with economical features, but it struggles in practical use. Users deem it too weak to handle typical pickup duties, whereas its lack of safety features leaves much to be desired. Buyers might find it more suitable as a project car than as a dependable vehicle.
10. 2020-2024 Jeep Gladiator
The modern Jeep Gladiator offers updated styling and technology but has not been void of criticism. Complaints of hard shifts, unexpected acceleration, and the notorious “Death Wobble” plague this model, causing waves of buyer hesitance among fans of the brand.
11. 2019 Ford F350
The fourth-generation Ford F-350 Super Duty trucks exhibit their own set of challenges, including the dreaded “Death Wobble” steering issue. Engine issues, suspension problems, and even concerns regarding potential fires have been highlighted, leading buyers to reconsider their choice.
12. 2010 Nissan Titan
While it initially seemed promising, the Nissan Titan became known for its problematic rear axle and frequent overheating. Issues like fuel pump failures and water leaks could result in extensive repairs. Still, the subsequent second generation eventually rectified most of these common complaints.
Avoiding Buyer’s Remorse
Purchasing a pickup truck shouldn’t feel like a gamble. Recognizing models that consistently underperform or suffer from reliability issues can save you from future headaches. While some of the trucks in our Haul of Shame have their dedicated followings, the cons presented in terms of performance often outweigh any potential benefits. Researching thoroughly before making your choice ensures you select a truck that gets the job done without distress.
Do you have your own tale of truck troubles? Share your experiences with us!